Humanists and the Occupy Movement

(Guest post by Rick Heller)

Occupy BostonI have been participating in the Occupy movement, and although I have held a sign outside Bank of America protesting policies that allow banks to be “too big to fail,” my main activity has been to lead meditations at Occupy Boston’s encampment across the street from the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston.

These meditations are based on those conducted at the Harvard Humanist Chaplaincy. The Humanist Mindfulness Group at Harvard has an orientation that can be described as “Secular Buddhist,” bearing a relationship to the Buddhist religion analogous to the relationship that Humanistic Judaism has with Orthodox Judaism.

When leading a meditation at Occupy Boston, I make clear that I don’t think meditators send out “vibes” that magically effect our financial institutions. Rather, these meditations have two purposes. The first is reducing stress, because living and sleeping in close quarters with others can be trying (I’m not a camper, only a day visitor). But more interesting is the possibility that meditative practices can directly contribute to the primary goal of the Occupy movement, which is to oppose the greed that led to speculative bubble and subsequent economic crash in 2008.

Newsweek has a cover story out on the science of why people overspend (I wrote on the same subject in the Humanist’s July/August issue). We have two motivational networks in the brain, one that focuses on immediate gratification and one on long-term payoffs. Neuroeconomist Paul Zak of Claremont Graduate University has found that when people receive injections of oxytocin, a hormone associated with loving feelings, they are better able to make financial decisions that require the deferral of immediate gratification. To put it simply, when you feel good now, you don’t need “retail therapy.”

With this in mind, I led a loving-kindness meditation in which you successively summon loving feelings toward yourself, a friend, a neutral person and finally, a person you find irritating. In a separate meditation, we were mindful of sounds. As Occupy Boston is next to a busy road and diagonal from a fire station, it provides a rich environment to practice receptive, loving attention to sounds usually thought of as “noise.”

Meditation and allied practices like psychotherapy can help us overcome our own greed, but they won’t magically overcome the greed of the “1%.” My hope is that young people in the Occupy movement can serve as role models to others in their generation who pursue materialistic aims. The current crisis has knocked a lot of young people off the career path they expected to be pursuing. They are examining alternative ways to live “the good life.” If the Humanist community were to engage with Occupy right now, I think we’d find a lot of young people open to our message.

Rick Heller is the author of the new eBook, Occupy the Moment.

  • Jon Figdor

    Great post Rick! Very thoughtful comments about meditation. I’m going to start doing the Sunday Humanist meditation, as the scientific evidence of its benefits is just too strong to deny at this juncture.

  • http://lauriesjobsearchtidbits.wordpress.com Laurie Holman

    Good post, Rick. I’ll bet a lot of people actually do subscribe to the theory that meditation sends out touchy-feely vibes that affect the banks. I think I feel a comedy skit coming on….

  • Anonymous

    An interesting peek into the Occupy movement from a humanist’s perspective.  The crisis has derailed many young people from their career ambitions.

  • Anonymous

    I applaud what you are doing 

  • Anonymous

    There was a time that they laughed at yogurt.

  • Jim Farmelant

    I laugh at yoghurt.

  • Jhutter41

    from a sociological perspective, it seems like a gathering of malcontents is being mistaken for a movement with a purpose. is the purpose to eliminate ”greed?” that’s as silly as protesting human nature. and really that’s a personal choice anyway. if we’re going to look at this logically, isnt it the case that the occupiers are more autocratic than the autocrats they despise since they truly believe they can identify who is greedy and who is not greedy?
    i believe this “movement” is more of a spiritual crisis for a younger generation who are horrified at the prospect of having to work for the next 45 yrs and just beginning to realize that they are not going to be millionaires or rock stars.   

    however, if the point is that meditation has a calming effect and induces a peaceful feeling, I find that indisputable. Perhaps if these groups wouldve meditated before pitching tents, they would have stayed home.

  • Abruzzo

    I am a Humanist.  I am also skeptical of both the Occupy Movement ans the Tea Party movement.  Although both movements claim to be speaking for a majority and that their economic views offer the greatest prosperity for the most people, I find their messages to be myopic and largely interested in scapegoating.

    The Tea Party activists argue that low taxes and an unregulated market will allow the country to bounce back.  However it was exactly the relaxation of laws regulating the housing market that lead to the recent perdicament.

    Occupy activits offer commendations for unions, while complaining constantly about “corporate greed” without once recognizing that unions are both corporations, greedy and behave very similar to the “coroprations” they despise .  Also can we dispense with the inaccuracy that unions represent “workers”.  They do not.  They represent “members”.  This is a very important, but usually overlooked distinction.

    Simply put, the individuals in both groups are looking after number one. They may be dedicated true beleivers of their principals but in the end their own well-being is what matters.

  • Dawsonbell

    I’m with this guy. I have an extensive distaste for burnouts that for some reason are just NOW paying attention to our very long term economic decline. These kids, as I had been unfortunate to witness firsthand, here in nyc, were the same kids that refer to themselves as anarchists, and pot heads that read tom robbins books. When will you get it? Karma is not real, and neither is prayer or the joke of an “oppositional meditational”. Fuck man, do your stupid stuff at home, dont hold me up on my way to work . Nobody cares; that includes the government-they would just kill you if they gave even an iota of care.

  • http://www.saclancelsoldes.org/ Lancel

    YJFLLBRMRYLOY I like it very much!

  • http://www.burberryoutlet2012.org/ burberry outlet

    JTZSJWMQZSB I like it very much!

  • http://www.lancelboutique.org/ sac lancel

    Le look élégant semble prêt à faire la fête

  • Gary100dm

     If all meditation did was help people stay calm and focused and reduce stress in the hectic world of the city, that itself would be of benefit. – Gary